I started by trying b).. putting a pad that Zoe used to sleep on next to our bed.. I realized that every time I moved, I was waking him up and this made a big difference.
Then 3 days ago I tried to take care of a)... no more night time nursing... and I had really been working on this for a long time, trying the Pantley-Pull-Off I remembered from the No-Cry Sleep method book for a long, long time. But the night before I tried for us to quit cold turkey, he had woke me up every hour for nursing. I didn't really think it was nursing, I though it was just pacifying, but cold turkey showed me that this was not the case.. I was so engorged no amount of daytime nursing was fixing it. Much to say, I gave that up after one night just for relief. But the good news is the 3 times of Finn screaming his lungs out and me just holding him and singing to him seemed to make a difference. For the past two night, he slept from 9:30 to 4am! Woke once for a feed and fell back asleep. The only thing that sucked about this is I'm so used to waking up, I don't sleep until 4am without waking and often couldn't get back to sleep, worried about the stuff that new moms worry about.. is the baby breathing, is he warm enough, is he cool enough... Mom sleep training is going to take longer.
A couple of "ahh..." moments that have come of this.
Last night Finn was screaming, didn't want to sleep, wanted to nurse to sleep, and I started Good Night Moon, but replace "cow" with "horse".. and he instantly snapped out of and said: "Horses say Neigh"
then this morning at 4am, after his feeding, he was falling asleep on his own, and he said the same thing.. "Horses say Neigh".... in his sleep.. it was so cute.